DailyBusiness.News

Daily Insights and news of Business, Industry and Market

NZ Lawyers Want Fewer Friday Settlements After a Microsoft Outage

NZ Lawyers Want Fewer Friday Settlements After a Microsoft Outage

When Microsoft 365 went down at 6.30am on Friday 13 November, New Zealand’s property lawyers had a particular reason to dread it. Friday is the country’s most popular day to settle a house sale, and Kristine King, who chairs the New Zealand Law Society’s property law section, estimates that between 2,000 and 3,000 settlements were due that day. More than 90% of them still went through. The ones that did not have reopened an old argument about Friday settlements, and this time the property bar is leading it.

The case is simple. A deal that fails on a Tuesday can be finished on Wednesday. A deal that fails on a Friday sits over the weekend, with interest charges running and families in limbo, until the banks reopen on Monday.

The Day Email Stopped Joining the Dots

For readers outside New Zealand, settlement is the day a home purchase completes. The buyer’s bank releases the loan, known as the drawdown; the lawyers on each side swap formal written promises called undertakings; the money lands with the seller; and the keys change hands. The payments themselves run through the banks’ same-day cleared payment system, but almost every confirmation in between travels by email.

That is the link the outage broke. Outlook, Teams, Copilot and OneDrive were all disrupted, and the Law Society said firms could not issue undertakings or receive bank drawdown information, NZ Lawyer reported. Melissa Choppin, a director at Rotorua firm MAC Legal, described the gap to the NZ Herald, in comments reported by NZ Lawyer: “The money might still be moving, but if the messages aren’t, everyone can be left wondering where things stand.”

King wrote to Law Society members that morning that the organisation was “urgently liaising” with banks on workarounds. Lawyers improvised with what they had. According to OneRoof, they used WhatsApp, Gmail, text messages and video calls to verify that funds had landed in the right accounts so ownership could transfer. King also asked banks to consider waiving interest charges where settlement money was left sitting in solicitors’ trust accounts because of the outage.

Some buyers and sellers still lost the day. OneRoof reported that a small number could not move as planned and had to find temporary accommodation for the weekend. Microsoft said there was no indication the failure was caused by malicious or cyber activity, and Stuff reported on the afternoon of Saturday 14 November that the company considered the outage resolved. By then the weekend had already started.

Why a Friday Failure Costs More

The weekend is what turns a delay into an expense. “Versus, if you fail to settle over Friday, you’ve got penalties running through the weekend, and you’re waiting until Monday to resolve it,” King told OneRoof, contrasting it with a Tuesday settlement that slips by a single day.

The penalties are not trivial. Loan Market mortgage broker Logan Reardon told OneRoof that one client could not go unconditional on a new-build purchase that Friday, because the bank advised the funds would not move until Monday. Going unconditional is the point at which a buyer is legally committed to the purchase. Had the client refused the delay, Reardon said, they could have faced penalty interest of between 14% and 21% a year, or in the worst case seen the deal collapse.

There is also a human chain at stake. Choppin explained to the Herald that a single delayed settlement can hold up the purchases that depend on it, because the seller in one deal is often the buyer in the next. Ray White Greenlane branch manager Frazer Mackenzie-Johnson recalled a vendor who spent up to four hours sitting in a moving truck outside a new home on the Hibiscus Coast while a settlement chain cleared, on a weekday when a fix was still possible.

The Agent Who Never Settles on a Friday

Mackenzie-Johnson says the outage only confirmed a rule a manager gave him early in his career: do not settle properties on Fridays. He still steers clients towards Thursday whenever he can. “People inherently want to do it on Friday for some reason, but the reality is if you do have a problem like we experienced last week, then you have this massive complication because settlements do not conclude at the weekend,” he told OneRoof.

The property bar agrees. “I’ve been saying it for years, and everybody ignores me, so that agent is so right,” King said. She argued that earlier settlements give banks and lawyers room to fix problems and look after clients, adding: “We would, as property lawyers, we would love our settlements to be spread during the week.”

Reardon, the broker, sees the same pinch from the lending side. “It’s a total cluster sometimes because there are so many settlements on a Friday as well,” he said, arguing the industry would benefit from deals spread more evenly through the week.

Why Banks Say Buyers Still Prefer Fridays

Not everyone wants fewer Friday settlements. Roger Beaumont, chief executive of the New Zealand Banking Association, told OneRoof that timing is usually driven by what customers want. “Friday is often the most convenient day because it allows homebuyers to move in and start unpacking at the weekend,” he said. He added that an earlier settlement “may also mean the buyer is repaying two home loans for a few days, which they may prefer to avoid.”

That is the real trade-off for households: a few days of double repayments against the tail risk of a weekend stuck between homes. Guardian Smith founder Mikey Smith put the case for Friday plainly, noting that the outage would have caused headaches whichever day it struck. “It wasn’t the end of the world. We’ve had banks do late settlements before without tech problems,” he said. His practical advice was different: “Don’t book your moving truck for 9am.”

The Business Lesson in a Single Point of Failure

The settlement scramble was the most visible part of a wider disruption. The Herald reported that court appearances were affected and that businesses across the country hunted for alternative ways to communicate. Paul Spain, chief executive of Gorilla Technology, estimated that tens of millions of dollars in productivity could be lost. Craig Young, chief executive of the Information Technology Users Association, said customers should expect compensation “especially if any loss can be clearly shown,” and added: “It shows how reliant we can become on a single provider and is a warning to have disruption plans.” A Microsoft Australia-New Zealand spokesman said the company had no comment on compensation at that stage.

The outage was not local. Al Jazeera reported that outage reports came from 74 countries and territories within about an hour of the first problems, which began at around 16:00 GMT on Thursday, or early Friday morning in New Zealand. For a conveyancing system that leans on one email provider to confirm money has moved, that concentration is the weakness.

The Law Society is already acting on it. NZ Lawyer reported that it is moving to set up backup emergency channels, such as SMS alerts, for future outages. The Real Estate Authority, whose licensee portal kept running but could not receive emails, said it was working with the property law section on a joined-up response.

What Changes Before the Next Outage

The Law Society’s own guidance from the day doubles as a checklist for the next one. In her letter to members, reported by NZ Lawyer, King urged practitioners to settle on a plan with the other side before anything else: “Agree how you will communicate and confirm receipt of important documents. Verify any alternative contact details directly with the other lawyer using a known phone number, and continue your usual checks before releasing funds.” That last line matters because a switch to personal email and messaging apps is exactly the moment when a fake payment instruction is hardest to spot, so the workaround has to be as careful as the system it replaces.

None of this rewrites the standard sale agreement, and buyers remain free to pick their settlement date. What has shifted is the advice. Agents such as Mackenzie-Johnson will keep pushing for Thursdays, the Law Society wants more midweek deals, and brokers are telling clients to leave room in the day before booking removal trucks. For households, the cost of a midweek settlement is easy to measure in a few days of overlapping loan repayments; the cost of a failed Friday only shows up when something breaks.

It is the same kind of fine print New Zealand firms have had to watch on payments, where a cap on commercial card fees promised savings of $40 million on paper. The lesson from 13 November is narrower and more practical: the busiest day of the week is also the one with no margin for error, and Friday settlements will stay the default only for as long as nothing goes wrong on them.

About The Author